(216) 240-5053

Is It Better To Repair Or Replace Your Deck In Ohio?

1918 Preservation

The allure of a well-maintained deck in Ohio, where outdoor spaces are cherished, can significantly enhance the enjoyment and value of your home. As the seasons change, decks endure the elements and natural wear, prompting homeowners to ponder the age-old question: Should I repair or replace my deck? In this comprehensive guide, we delve into the multifaceted considerations that can influence this pivotal decision. From understanding the lifespan of different deck materials to identifying nuanced signs that call for repairs or replacements, we embark on a detailed exploration. Our aim is to empower Ohio homeowners, providing insights that help them make informed choices for the longevity and vibrancy of their cherished outdoor spaces.

What’s The Lifespan Of A Deck?

Deciding whether to embark on a repair journey or opt for a full deck replacement hinges on a crucial understanding of the deck’s lifespan and the material it’s composed of. In the Ohio landscape, where decks are subjected to varying weather conditions, the longevity of these outdoor structures can differ.
Wood decks, with a lifespan of around 15 years, exude a timeless appeal but require meticulous care. Meanwhile, composite decking offers a more robust endurance of 20 to 25 years, making it a popular choice for its resilience to the elements. Surprisingly, capped polymer decks can boast an impressive longevity of up to 50 years, standing as a testament to modern engineering.

When the deck approaches the twilight of its lifespan and exhibits substantial damage, rot, or wear in multiple areas, the case for a full replacement becomes compelling. However, if the deck still has years left in its expected life and the wear and tear is more superficial – think splintering or fading – opting for the strategic replacement of individual boards might be a pragmatic solution.

Signs You Need To Repair Your Deck

Regular deck maintenance is not just a chore; it’s a proactive investment in the long-term health of your outdoor haven. To gauge when repairs are in order, an end-of-summer or early fall deck inspection is invaluable. Here are common issues to watch for:

Popped Nails or Loose Screws:

Vigilantly spot any popped nails, loose screws, or fasteners that might compromise the structural integrity of your deck. A timely fix involves prying up the loose fasteners and replacing them with new screws or nails.

Cracked/Splintered Wood:

Cracks or splits in the wood not only mar the aesthetic appeal but also jeopardize the structural integrity of your deck. For one or two affected boards, consider a targeted replacement. However, if numerous boards show signs of distress, signaling a more widespread problem, a comprehensive repair strategy may be necessary.

Loose Railings And Floorboards:

A deck should exude stability, and loose railings or floorboards compromise this essential quality. Swiftly address the issue by replacing the fasteners or the boards in question. However, if the entire deck structure feels unstable, indicating a deeper problem, a more extensive repair or a strategic replacement may be the wisest course.


Rust can render metal components weak and brittle, posing a threat to the overall stability of your deck. Regularly inspect for any rusty hardware and replace it promptly to maintain structural integrity and extend the lifespan of your cherished outdoor space.


The weather can be harsh on your deck’s appearance. Faded or weather-stained wood is a common issue, but fear not, as it can be rectified with a thorough cleaning, targeted board replacement, and staining. This not only revitalizes the appearance of your deck but also adds an extra layer of protection against the elements.

Signs You Need To Replace Your Deck

While judicious repairs can breathe new life into a deck, certain issues may necessitate a more profound solution: a complete replacement. As autumn approaches, conduct a meticulous inspection to uncover the following problems:

Wood is Rotted or Splintering:

Widespread wear-and-tear is a strong indicator that a deck may be approaching the end of its serviceable life. If the majority of floorboards display cracks, splintering, and bowing, and you observe pervasive wood rot, simple repairs may not be adequate. Prying up and replacing a few floorboards is a manageable task, but if every floorboard requires attention, it might signal the need for a comprehensive deck replacement.

Ledger Board is Damaged:

The ledger board, a critical component that connects your deck to your house, requires special attention. If you notice loose fittings or signs of rot, it’s advisable to consult a professional to determine the best course of action. A damaged ledger board often warrants a deck replacement, ensuring the structural integrity of the entire system.

The Foundation is No Longer Structurally Sound:

Safety is paramount, and if the entire deck feels shaky underfoot, accompanied by cracks or splintering in the foundation posts, immediate action is imperative. An unsecured deck is not only an inconvenience but also poses a serious safety risk. In such instances, consulting a professional becomes crucial to ensure that your next deck build is solid, secure, and aligned with the latest safety standards.

Why Call 1918 Preservation For Expert Wood Deck Repairs In Perry, Ohio

As the summer sun beckons and the desire to entertain guests on your deck grows, the need for reliable and expert wood deck repair services becomes paramount. In Perry, Ohio, and its surrounding areas, 1918 Preservation LLC stands as a trusted ally in transforming your outdoor space into a haven of comfort and aesthetic allure.

Revel in the warmth of summer gatherings on a flawlessly restored deck, meticulously repaired by our team of seasoned professionals. Our expertise extends beyond mere repairs; we are dedicated to ensuring that your outdoor retreat remains not only functional but also seamlessly aligned with your unique needs and preferences.

Schedule your deck repair with 1918 Preservation LLC today and embark on a journey to revitalize your deck, enhancing both its longevity and visual appeal. In Perry, Ohio, we take pride in being the go-to solution for all your deck repair needs. Reach out to us, and let 1918 Preservation LLC elevate your deck experience to new heights.

Call or Text Us